Thread: 2nd state of origion.Who watched

Not a bad game.From a NSW point of view.

Wolfman williams needs to be dropped and the person who put him in there should be dropped.He was shocking.


We need a better goal kicker.Could of been 18 all if gidley got those goals in.

I know hazem elmasri is pretty old, but he maybe could of been useful.

Hayne and watmough had excellent games.Them two together were better than the whole nsw team put together.

They should of brough in Josh Morris earlier.I think he would of been better than Monaghan.

Gidley is overrated.

Your thoughts?

NSW got smashed back to back even though QLD played shit in the second game they still won.

Love it.

Originally Posted by Beeman

NSW got smashed back to back even though QLD played shit in the second game they still won.

I'm a Blues supporter and I agree.

Hayne and Watmough were the only players on the NSW team that played with any kind of heart. Who the hell is Giddley playing for .. the Under 14's.. FFS I'm of the majority of NSW players just turning up for a game and an extra pay packet they (the Blues players) just don't care..

QLD played crap.. and still got soft try after soft try ...

NSW effort.. PATHETIC!

Great game :)

First half both teams made too many mistakes. QLD was robbed of late try by video ref. I was waiting all game for someone to even the score on Trent Barret. 2nd half was a different ball game. Both teams had much better ball security & defense was tighter. I was worried for a while there that the blues would come home over a tired & injured QLD. The boys showed great heart in defense to hold on. And that last try was sweet.

Originally Posted by anthony

Not a bad game.From a NSW point of view.

Wolfman williams needs to be dropped and the person who put him in there should be dropped.He was shocking.


We need a better goal kicker.Could of been 18 all if gidley got those goals in.

I know hazem elmasri is pretty old, but he maybe could of been useful.

Hayne and watmough had excellent games.Them two together were better than the whole nsw team put together.

They should of brough in Josh Morris earlier.I think he would of been better than Monaghan.

Gidley is overrated.

Your thoughts?

williams did well , he dropped the ball on 2 occasions to 2 great tackles. Anyone would of dropped the ball if hit by them tackles. He plays great for manly and australia there is noone else to put there. El masri? LOL thats all i will say.

Gidley is a brilliant player he tried his heart out.

Farah out Ennis in
Weyman on bench
Perry in Poore out
Glen Stewart out someone else in
lyon out - Cooper in
barrett out (never shld of been there ) - Soward or mullen in.

Nsw can fuck off and die. They are a disgrace to the concept of origin.


... Bit strong? Well that's what you get for having no heart.

and why not take a gamble on kimmorley... Better than nothing.

I don't think gidley played bad. I didnt think he had a strong game, but he did make that try saving tackle in inglis.

Standouts were:

Jarrod haine - awsome
Watmough- should start he is an animal
trent barrett - i though he had a strong game

Most of the forwards were strong - i think slater will be bruised tomorrow... he was shut down everytime by the forwards. Except they let falou get that weak try

dishonorable mentions:

Peter Wallace - had a horrible game. First he lets a pass go straight pass him that drops on the ground thats picked up by a qlder who nearly scores, then he passes a ball forward on to the ground. He was horrible.

Wolfman - or whatever his name his... he sucked... get off the field

Lyon - he sucked

weyman - didnt have a strong or weak game, but i wouldnt put him in the team

Originally Posted by Bricktop

and why not take a gamble on kimmorley... Better than nothing.

kimmorley has had his chance. Wallace was best choice his playing for a great team and is in great form. I like mitchell pearce but u cant pick him for the very reason the roosters are rock bottom but i beleive pearce is the future for nsw

Originally Posted by Beeto

kimmorley has had his chance. Wallace was best choice his playing for a great team and is in great form. I like mitchell pearce but u cant pick him for the very reason the roosters are rock bottom but i beleive pearce is the future for nsw

Im not so sure. As a avid Broncos supporter i do not think Wallace is in the best form, while Kimmorley is.

Trent Barrett "had his chance " as well, but they still picked him again, after a absencse of some years.

Its got nothing to do with 'having a chance' and everyhting to do with form. Kimmorley is in form and his team is at the top of the table, the Broncos are not.

Kimmorley is the logical choice.

kimmorley has NOT performed at origin level and has been given so many chances. Barrett should of never been chosen.

Originally Posted by Bricktop

Nsw can fuck off and die. They are a disgrace to the concept of origin.


... Bit strong? Well that's what you get for having no heart.

Peace bro. That was a bit out of character!

Shit game...so many mistakes in the first 20. I'm a NSW supporter but QLD should have been awarded that fourth try and the game should have been over at half time. Anyhow, the best team did win.

Originally Posted by azzah

Peace bro. That was a bit out of character!

that does depend on which character you are talking about! ;)

, but I can't stand teams with no ticker, they got no heart!

Who watched.... everyone I know.
Great game, better side won once again!

Originally Posted by Beeto

kimmorley has NOT performed at origin level and has been given so many chances. Barrett should of never been chosen.

Wally Lewis believes kimmorley should be in for nsw, that's a big endorsement.