Hey Matt, first of all I salute you for being so honest in open forum, and have had this similar question from a few people privately.
A great number of things can cause your problem, from meds, drugs, tiredness, anxiety, overuse...
It would seem to me that you have yourself in a vicious cycle of anxiety related to performance. This will make it a whole lot worse.
Your girlfriend is concerned that she's not pleasing you - first of all, clone her! (jokes).
What you may need to do here is try to start fresh. Hit the couples stuff, romance, a few wines, massage, warm shower/bath, more foreplay and try not to make the end result the be all and end all. The process itself is supposed to be pretty good too! Try something different, depending on what you're into, and I'll leave that there for now...
Safe sex message: If you're using condoms, maybe try a thinner variety to ensure you get more stimulation.
Communication - she needs to understand that you are satisfied with her, that she's a good lover, because at the moment she feels that she's failing you. I also think too much of a good thing here has occurred. Take a step back and don't saturate so much of your relationship with sex. Of course you're getting to know each other, and this is honeymoon stuff. However, be a little more conservative with sex and your energies. A build up of tension is perhaps what's needed.
She's 19. I'm not sure how old you are mate, but I'm thinking early/mid twenties from memory. She's still emotionally immature so you may need to really spend some time communicating how you feel, listening to how she feels and do some reassuring.
Spend more time on her. Get to know her body a little more, and teach her about yours.
I don't know why we Aussies are so fucked up over sex sometimes (and I'm not generalising), whether it's some kind of guilt we feel, shame or whether we still think some things are taboo topics. More communication is needed, more honesty.
Matt, at the end of the day mate, there's nothing wrong with you and I doubt you need medication. Try to avoid the anxiety associated with performance, because at the moment you're conditioning yourself to think that every time you have sex you won't be able to perform, she'll be let down and feel like she's failed you. It's a recipe for disaster.
Take a step back, spend some time getting to know each other and your bodies in other ways and be open and honest with each other and how you feel. You may be surprised at how a little reassurance can go a long way.
Drop me a PM if you need to chat more, and thanks for sharing.
If anyone else has any support for Matt, feel free to post or PM him.
BD
Winners make it happen...losers let it happen.
Qui audet adipiscitur.